The review for this book has been challenging for me. I crafted three different reviews before landing on this one and much of this one was cut out to keep it a readable length. I had hoped to avoid writing a review based
mainly on one chapter of a book but after wrestling with it for a while I
realized it was unavoidable.
Real Marriage by Mark and Grace Driscoll is their
contribution to a topic widely written on, namely marriage. However their
approach to the topic is very different than most marriage books I have read. Perhaps that was their point. True to his form Mark’s “spade a spade” approach
to life is not softened much by bringing his wife in as a writing companion.
The book is topically broken up into three parts but I found
them, from the reader's perspective, to be rather incohesive.
Part one entitled "Marriage"
speaks mainly of the need for husbands and wives to be friends. They encourage
couples to foster honesty and openness and to maintain friendship through regular “date nights”. Mark writes a chapter to men on honoring their wives
which I found to be a bit bromidic. However Grace’s chapter to wives on the
subject of respecting their husbands offered wise and practical helps that
brought specific challenge to me personally.
Of the five chapters in this section the one that stood out to me the
most was the chapter entitled “Taking out the Trash”. In this chapter the
Driscolls bring the gospel to life. They helpfully address the need for
forgiveness and repentance in marriage and how the struggles we face are gospel
issues and Jesus Christ is the only hope; “Sin is the problem. The gospel of
Jesus Christ is the answer.” This was the best chapter in this section and
maybe even in the entire book. Overall this section does have many practical
helps and advice but it lacked depth and probably could have been summed up in
a mini-book. But if you are looking for some quotes that pack a punch you will find them in that section.
Part two is suitably entitled "Sex". This is where the book
takes a concerning turn in my opinion. Although sex is a topic appropriate for
a marriage book the approach and the amount of detail given to the subject
seemed over the top (Driscollesque I suppose). Over the course of the next 5
chapters the Driscolls discuss topics often only talked about in the most
private of settings. They dive into issues of abuse (using Grace’s own story),
wrong views of sex, pornography, selfish vs. servant loving (pulling this time
from Mark’s story), and lastly the most controversial of chapters titled “Can
we____?” It is this section and specifically that chapter where I have
significant concern.
While there are particular truths and helpful
statistics in this section of the book, there is also much that seems
inappropriate even for a marriage book. Besides what seems to be a lack of
discernment in discussing such private subjects publically, the use of
1 Corinthians 6:12 to explore what married couples can and cannot do seems
contextually liberal. Using this verse, the Driscolls, discuss very sensitive issues under three questions: Is it lawful? Is it
helpful? Is it enslaving? While this verse
can be an excellent guide and gauge it is not exhaustive enough to be the sole
compass to navigate such sensitive areas discussed in this book. When you are
looking at something as relational as sex there are more specific scripture that
will ask deeper questions. Does it
glorify God (
1Cor. 10:31)? Does it honor the marriage bed (
Heb.13:4)? Does it
help me fulfill the 1
st and 2
nd great commandments (
Matt22:237-39)? To name only a few. In
addition the Driscolls allow personal conscience to be a determining factor to answer
the question “Is it helpful?” Our consciences are not free from the effect and
influence of sin and so to allow freedom of conscience to determine if
something is permissible is unwise. But
a significant area of concern comes from the reality that this chapter does not
address what is motivating the question “Can we ____?” The motive of the heart is left out of why a
couple would be seeking to engage in some of the sexual acts in this book. Avoiding the issue of motives of the heart will often allow sin to go uncovered. Leaving that key component out opens up opportunity for significant
misunderstanding and hurt in a relationship.
My concern is that this chapter will draw couples who are
struggling in this area. They may come to it looking for help in the
safe and private walls of a book when in reality some one-on-one counsel with a wise and experienced biblical counselor may be more what they need (both as a couple and individually). I am also concerned that the application of this chapter may lead to more harm than good in marriages due to a lack of taking a significant heart check on the issue.
The third section of the book confused me. It is titled "The Last Day". It gives encouragement to look not to the first day of marriage
but to the last. It then rolls out to be something like a homework assignment you
would get from a life coach. Following such revealing and deep issues
addressed in the previous chapter not only did it feel like a jolt in subject
but seemed far from where a couple would
care to go after the topics just addressed. I believe this chapter would have
been more suited for an appendix item rather than a concluding chapter, which
basically means the book had no ending. No real direction. No final concrete application
of truth to hold on to. It just kind of left me feeling a little unsure.
The book has wisdom in it and there are things to be
learned from it here and there. The statistics alone were insightful and Mark’s
direct approach to the effects of pornography is spot on. But the value of it is not outweighed by the indelicate approach to the topic of sex and that makes me not recommend it.
As a
biblical counselor I know that much of what they addresses in this book is sadly all too common even in Christian marriages. Our tendency is to just be
silent and pretend we are not effected. I am not promoting silence but at
the same time I certainly would not encourage people to author books about most
things that come up in the counseling room. There are appropriate places to
discuss private issues and even then discretion must be considered.
As a woman
there were times I felt the delivery of some of the content was bordering on
crude.
As a wife I am not going to pass
this one on to my husband although I
read many parts to him to get his thoughts. They raised similar concerns in him.
As a mother of teen children (who read this blog) I will not be leaving this
book around on the coffee table.
As a Christian I greatly appreciate the Driscolls' integrity to the gospel and I respect their willingness to be so honest with their struggle. I have misgivings about some of their interpretation of Scripture as well as the use of their influence to speak so unashamedly to things that just might fall under things too "
shameful even to mention".